Dealership Marketing

Web 2.0 Essential for Dealers to Survive Economic Crisis

Guest Posting by Audrey Knoth

These days, the most believable voices come from individuals, not what your dealers says about itself.

As one who subscribes to Automotive News daily alerts, I’ve come to expect a several-times-a-day dose of once unthinkable news about the auto industry. There may not have been many tears shed over the collapse of the world’s largest Chevrolet dealer, save for those who depended upon it for their livelihoods. We all feel deeply for them. But the fact a giant could topple so suddenly shows how fast change can come, even in the industry long heralded as America’s largest.

Of course, the economy and business are cyclical. After the bad times, the good times inevitably return. However, my firm has handled public relations for auto dealers for more than 15 years and I believe that the industry is facing a watershed moment. Unless dealers embrace the principles of Web 2.0 now, when prosperity comes back, a lot of those who made it through the downturn won’t survive the upswing.

Accompanying the economic crisis is a crisis in consumer trust. People no longer believe what institutions and organizations tell them. I hardly need to detail why; a glance through the headlines about financial executives publicly vaunting their companies right up until their collapse spells it out clearly. But consumer mistrust is not confined to the financial sector. Think about it: who unabashedly believes what any company or entity says about itself anymore?

These days, the most believable voices come from individuals. The recommendation, criticism, or opinion that matters to each of us now is that of a peer – someone else who is “just like me.” In considering a significant purchase, we want to know what someone else “like me” has to say about the product and the experience of buying it. Consumers routinely Google for these comments prior to opening their wallets. What the company selling that product says falls into the category of “information to consider, but not necessarily believe.”

This shift in consumer attitudes has profound significance for the auto industry, which has grappled with decades of public mistrust, anyway. The car business has been struggling to come to terms with Web 2.0. Most executives continue to fear what consumers would say if they opened their sites to dialogue and customer comments. They figure it’s safer not to engage and so the majority of them don’t.

But what may seem safe now is exactly what will prevent many auto dealers from succeeding when the current crisis is over. After the dark economic clouds clear, the sun will be shining on a new era – one in which consumers will be able to spend money, but will only be willing to do so with companies endorsed by “people like me.” Woe betide auto dealers who are not onboard and ready with Web 2.0 then.

Dealers should use this slow period to invest time, resources, and yes, money, into transforming themselves into Web 2.0 operations. Of course, it’s not just a matter of redesigning the dealership’s web site. It’s also a question of training all staff throughout the organization to walk the walk in terms of truly exceptional customer service that builds relationships.

Dealership principals need to give Web 2.0 a seat at the executive table. For dealers who embrace this, the return of the good times will absolutely be great.

About the Author: Audrey Knoth is the Executive Vice President
for Goldman & Associates Public Relations

K
This is a fantastic piece - and dead-on. My biggest battle as an eCommerce Director is to get folks within this industry to CHANGE with the market, and embrace it, rather than fight it. The longer folks have worked in this industry, the more stubborn they get in their ways. I cannot imagine a bigger change in the auto-buying market than what is going on now. People are tired of buying cars the "old way", the way we have always sold them. Now, the control has shifted thanks to the internet, and our shoppers wield more power. If they don't like being called over and over, they put you on the do not call list. If they don't like getting 14 emails a day, they mark you as spam. If they are not ready to buy now, they ignore your attempts to contact them until they are ready. If you do not give them a price quote - they just go to the dealer that will. If you won't give them a trade-in appraisal, they just look online and get it themselves. Playing ostrich and burying your head in the sand will not work - and unfortunately many dealers do just that, they try to pretend that if they just ignore these changes they will go away... The dealers that embrace Web 2.0, and work to meet the needs of our customers will win. Our challenge is to put these changes into place at our respective workplaces... Kevin Frye/eCommerce Director/Jeff Wyler Automotive Family
A
  • A
    Audrey Knoth
  • November 5, 2008
Kevin, thank you for your compliment and comments. As you pointed out, ultimately, the market will force this change upon dealers ... what I don't understand is why dealers aren't proactively making the change now. A lot of dealers got to where they are today by taking risks ... but I guess the longer one is in any line of work, it becomes easier to play it safe. In this case, it will be safe now and sorry later ...
M
I think that the fear of the unknown has a part in dealers not getting onboard with the whole user generated content craze. Some are afraid of what they may find out about their operations and then to have it on display for everyone to read.

Another problem I see is that many dealers tried to change but didn't have the right people, processes and tools to make it happen. That left them with a bad taste in their mouth so they are reluctant to try again.
B
  • B
  • November 5, 2008
It's the lack of control that dealers feel when dealing with an internet customer.

Back in the day, they had control because customers came to the dealership to get all their information. Once inside, control belonged to the dealer.

Most of them are deathly afraid of this new customer.

Audrey you are so correct in that dealers were so ready to take risks until the internet came along. Give them control and they're all in again.
A
Loss of control is not unique to dealerships. Large multinationals (e.g. Coke, WalMart, OEMs) are no longer in complete control of how their brand is represented. Media companies are fighting (and too often, losing) to keep their content from being distributed freely. But these companies are so large that even when they had their heads stuck in the sand, they were forced to confront (or at least manage) the changes in the market due to the Internet and especially Web 2.0. It seems that many dealerships will only address these issues when the monetary losses become too significant to ignore. And by then it may be too late.
Audrey,

I can't thank you enough for a great subject and a great post.

I truly fear the outcome for many dealers across the United States. I hear of dealers closing their doors and selling out almost daily.

I know of TOP performing dealers that do <i>have</i> a grasp on Web 2.0 but are still facing rough times. They are keeping afloat but are of course still feeling the dip.

To be fair though..we have hit a crises in the economy while 2.0 is still in it's infancy. Most dealer are still trying to figure out the 101, so having them on board with 2.0 is not expected (though needed).

Something that I have seen and maybe some others can confirm; though over all sales are dramatically down, Internet accredited sales percentages seem to be at their highest (or have stayed the same).

What does this tell us?? Something most of us already know; customers are spending more and more time online researching. They are becoming more analytic and are buying based on facts and needs rather emotion. This is another reason I believe dealers are struggling with floor sales. Sales people are and have been trained (plus it comes natural) to sell on emotion. This is currently causing conflict with the consumer and giving them more reason to "have to think about it" while going back home to get more facts.

More time online equates to more searches, more fact finding and MORE opportunities to engage with Web 2.0 avenues. More opportunities to find and be influenced by the a dealers online reputation.

Lets get even more granular! Customers spending more time online, more time to be influenced, more time to gather facts, MORE TIME TO EXPRESS THEIR OWN EXPERIENCE they just had with the dealer trying to sell them on emotion.

I have no doubt this is happening. I see it first hand.

Dealers desperately need to get on board and grasp the true understanding of web 2.0, transparency, relationship based selling. It's more than just "web". It's a movement and one that has been even more fueled by the crises of the economy.
R
Yes, this is a good topic, but keep in mind that "Web 2.0" is just a temporary label identifying a permanent situation - Interactive Marketing or User Contributed Marketing as Jeff suggests above.

The mountain I see needing to be climbed by dealers is shifting from a culture of "vehicle leads" to "customer audience". With Web 2.0, the objective is to develop an engaged audience, not generate vehicle inquiries. Of course, you are developing this audience for the interest of your business.

For instance, when you hold your next tent event, consider some <a href="http://blog.autoconversion.net/social-marketing/facebook-ideas-car-dealers/" rel="nofollow">possible uses for Facebook</a>.

Good stuff Audrey.
A
  • A
    Audrey Knoth
  • November 10, 2008
Thank you, Jeff and Ryan, for your kind comments ... Jeff, regarding your point about the current economic crisis ... it's all the more reason for dealers to embrace Web 2.0 now. First off, of course, there is its cost-effectiveness, and that factor alone should speak volumes. Beyond that, economic disruption always forces change. The victors are the ones who innovate so they are ready for the new era. Ryan, your point about building a culture of "customer audience" rather than "vehicle leads" is the perfect way to put it ... and also why I believe that the dealership's web/e-commerce directorship should be a top-level executive function, because the company's web presence cuts across all departments. When you consider it from the standpoint of "customer audience," you realize this audience is comprised of sales customers, service customers, body shop customers, and other audiences, such as potential employees. This is central to the dealership's identity and needs to be advocated at the top. Again, thanks for your comments!
S
  • S
    Stan Sher
  • November 15, 2008
This is the time when dealers start to separate the strong managers from the weak ones. They realize they waste money on weak ones and let them go. This is also the time to really start embracing the internet because it is the wave. The future is already here, they just need to grap onto it. This is where internet specialists and consultants should really be working to help shape the industry to be eCommerce friendly...
T
  • T
    Tony Weaver
  • November 15, 2008
Allowing customers to have full reign of your site would be a huge step, no doubt about it. After much thought on this idea, and after taking a beating the other day from people on this site in another posting, I decided to investigate this alleged customer phenomenon quoted as, “After the dark economic clouds clear, the sun will be shining on a new era – one in which consumers will be able to spend money, but will only be willing to do so with companies endorsed by “people like me.” Woe betide auto dealers who are not onboard and ready with Web 2.0 then.” I do not know why, but after reading that comment, the hype of Y2K comes to mind. “Never mind that. Let’s be positive!” they say!

Just the other day, after reading this post, I was thinking about purchasing a space heater for my home. In the interest of saving time, I went to the Wal-Mart website to see what they had listed for sale. I found what I was looking for and read the reviews on the product. There were two positive remarks and one negative remark. Satisfied with the positive feedback, I went to Wal-Mart last night and bought the space heater. Did the comments regarding the heater sway my decision? YES, of course they did!

Well heck, maybe it would be great to have customer comments on new or used vehicles on our site. What could be the harm? After all, if the comments are made by real people, everything should be fine - especially if our dealership is customer service orientated.

I figure that there would need to be some checks and balances. For example: requiring any person, wishing to leave a comment, to have their email verified before the comment is posted. I actually tried to leave a comment on Wal-Mart.com and there was a process I had to follow to have my comment posted on the site. Basically, I had to be a real person. I have found this to be the case on most other sites. They will not allow someone without a name and a confirmable e-mail to post on their site. This process prevents people from ranting or making lewd remarks.

Yesterday, I took this whole idea of customer reviews a step further. My dealership group is spread out across a couple of states so we have three website providers. I contacted each of these companies and pitched the idea of adding customer reviews or maybe a question and answer section (like the one on e-Bay). All three venders shot down the idea. The rep at each website provider told me to just use the “News” or “About us” section on my site(s) and put written testimonials with pictures, or video testimonials up. They all treated me as if I was absolutely insane and I thought I was for asking them because I new what the outcome would be…

So guys and gals, if you want this, you are going to have to request these reviews to be built to your sites now! Or, like the author of this post indicated, we may become victims of this Web 2.0 phenomenon - or not…
A
  • A
    Audrey Knoth
  • November 19, 2008
Hi, Tony: How interesting about your reading the reviews about the space heater and then making your decision. This is absolutely the way consumer purchasing behavior is going. If consumers don't find reviews on a retailer's web site, they google for them elsewhere. By keeping their websites closed off to customer reviews, dealers are not going to prevent customers from putting their opinions online about the vehicles they bought and the service they received. They are simply going to cause customers to find other places on the web to post them. I agree there has to be review of submitted customer comments for senseless ranted and lewd language before they are posted ... and consumers generally understand and accept the necessity of that process. Managing the comments is important in another way, too, because the dealership can post responses to any comments it feels are negative. These responses could be things like, "Thanks for pointing that out to us; we looked into it and took care of it this morning" ... etc, etc, etc. Web 2.0 isn't going away for dealers ... it's just the smart ones will get on board now so they are ahead of the curve for whatever Web 3.0 is going to be.
T
  • T
    Tony Weaver
  • November 19, 2008
Audrey,
Yes, now find me a vender that will actually do it. Maybe in two years??? Automotive web site venders are always late in developing the what is happening now stuff. Hopefully, dealer.com will work with me on this...
E
Thought provoking post, Audrey. I can see 2009 becoming the year of <a href="http://dealerflow.com/2009/1/1/dealer-web-2-0" rel="nofollow">dealer Web 2.0</a>. A surprise may be the use of Web 2.0 inside organizations as differentiated from strict marketing. Use of Web 2.0 internally could positively impact the use of such tools for customer facing activity by training the entire dealer workforce on Web 2.0 concepts and tools.

I agree with you that smart dealers will look at this slow period as the time tackle a new model like Web 2.0.
E